Carrie Underwood’s “Softly and Tenderly” at the CMA Awards Didn’t Just Move the Room—It Broke It Open.
When Carrie Underwood stepped into the spotlight at the 51st Annual CMA Awards, no one expected what was about to happen. Dressed in a floor-length gown that shimmered under the stage lights, she stood motionless for a moment. The room was hushed—not the polite quiet before a performance, but the deep, almost reverent stillness that means something is about to cut straight to the bone.
The first notes of “Softly and Tenderly” floated into the air, carried by the gentlest touch of piano and steel guitar. The hymn, written over a century ago, is one of the most enduring invitations to grace in Christian music. But in this moment, it was not just a song. It was a gathering of grief, a salve for the brokenhearted, and a prayer wrapped in melody.
And then—it happened. Her voice trembled. Her eyes welled up. The weight of what she was singing wasn’t just visible—it was palpable. This wasn’t performance polish; it was vulnerability on display. By the second verse, many in the audience were already wiping their own tears.
The Context: More Than a Performance
The 2017 CMA Awards took place just weeks after one of the darkest moments in country music history—the Route 91 Harvest Festival shooting in Las Vegas, where 58 concertgoers were killed. It was the deadliest mass shooting in modern American history, and it had left the country music community shaken to its core.
For many in that room, the faces of friends, colleagues, and fans lost in the tragedy were still painfully fresh in their minds. “Softly and Tenderly,” with its gentle plea—Come home, come home, ye who are weary, come home—wasn’t just chosen for its beauty. It was chosen because it was the only thing that could meet the grief head-on.
Underwood wasn’t just singing. She was holding space for the loss, for the pain, for the memory of those who would never walk into another concert venue again.
The Moment the Room Changed
By the second chorus, something shifted. You could see people in the crowd grasping hands, bowing heads, even closing their eyes as if in prayer. This was not the usual award-show performance with applause breaks and camera-ready smiles. The atmosphere was sacred.
The massive video screen behind Underwood began displaying photographs—names, faces, lives. It wasn’t just for those lost in Las Vegas. The montage also honored country music legends and industry figures who had passed away in the past year. The room became a chapel, the audience a congregation.
And then the camera panned to Underwood again. Her voice, clear yet trembling, seemed to come from a place far deeper than rehearsal or technical skill. It was as if she were singing straight from the ache in her chest.
Why This Performance Hit Different
Country music has long been a home for storytelling, for songs about love, loss, and resilience. But in a world of slick production and fast-moving entertainment cycles, it’s easy for even the most heartfelt performances to be consumed and forgotten.
This one wasn’t.
“Softly and Tenderly” that night wasn’t about chart success or vocal gymnastics. It wasn’t even about Carrie Underwood as a star. It was about the raw human need for comfort when life shatters without warning.
There is a particular kind of beauty in music that doesn’t try to “fix” pain but simply sits with it. Underwood didn’t rush the tempo. She didn’t belt to prove a point. She let the song breathe, leaving space between the notes for the grief in the room to exist.
Faith, Loss, and the Love That Stays
If you strip away the glitter of the CMA stage, what you’re left with in this performance is a core truth: some love never leaves. The people we lose are still woven into our days—in the songs that remind us of them, in the way certain words catch in our throats, in the moments we wish they could have seen.
The hymn itself is steeped in that hope, offering not only comfort but also the promise of reunion:
Earnestly, tenderly, Jesus is calling—
Calling, O sinner, come home.
For the country community, many of whom grew up on hymns just like this one, those words carried a weight beyond doctrine. They were an open hand, a reminder that even in loss, love endures.
The Aftermath: Silence, Then Standing
When the final note faded, there was no immediate roar of applause. For several seconds, the room just sat in the quiet, holding the moment like a fragile piece of glass. Then, slowly, the audience rose to its feet—not in the burst of energy you see after a high-tempo number, but in a wave of quiet respect.
It wasn’t just a standing ovation. It was a collective acknowledgment that they had just shared something profoundly human.
Backstage later, Underwood admitted that the performance had been one of the most emotional of her career. “It was hard to get through,” she said, her voice still thick with feeling. “But I knew it was something I had to do.”
Why We Still Talk About It
Years later, clips of that performance still circulate online. In the comments, people share where they were when they first saw it, or how it helped them through their own losses. Many say they’ve watched it dozens of times, each viewing bringing back the same wave of emotion.
In a world saturated with content, it’s rare for a performance to maintain its emotional impact over time. But “Softly and Tenderly” at the CMAs was never about fleeting attention. It was about truth. And truth—especially when sung with that much heart—doesn’t expire.
For Those Who Think Country Music Can’t Shake Them Anymore
It’s easy to dismiss country music as all trucks, beer, and heartbreak clichés if you only glance at the surface. But when you dig deeper, you find songs that hold entire worlds—songs that sit at the bedside in grief, that stand in the pews at funerals, that remind you of your grandmother’s kitchen or the church you grew up in.
This performance was one of those reminders. It proved that country music can still reach down into the tender places and stir something you thought was gone.
The Prayer We Didn’t Expect
In the end, “Softly and Tenderly” at the CMA Awards wasn’t an interlude in the night’s entertainment—it was the heart of it. It was a prayer whispered straight from Carrie Underwood’s soul to everyone watching, in the room and at home.
It was for the fans who will never come home from a concert.
It was for the families left holding photographs instead of hands.
It was for anyone who has ever sat in the hollow of loss and wondered if the ache would ever ease.
And maybe, in some small way, it was for Carrie herself—because even those who sing comfort need it too.
If you’ve ever doubted that a single song could stop a room cold, let this be your proof. Watch the video, and you’ll feel it: the hush, the tremble, the ache, the unshakable love.
Some performances entertain. A rare few heal. This was one of them.
Leave a Reply